Anmerkung

Original fragment recitative version. In likelihood the usually-performed air in part I is an arrangement of this.

See the notes by John Butt in https://musicbrainz.org/release/6ced19c3-4937-44c5-81b7-9df7b25c3fab

"Although a recitative version does indeed survive for ‘But who may abide’, this is found in sources considerably later than those used for Dublin, and may well be of doubtful authenticity. ... For this recording, we have decided to adopt the full bass version of the aria in the sequence of the recording, placing the surviving recitative version in the appendix of disc 1."

Anmerkung zuletzt geändert am 2026-03-06 10:20 UTC.

Beziehungen

Komponist(in):George Frideric Handel (German‐British baroque composer)
Arrangement von:Messiah, HWV 56: Part I, no. 6. Air “But who may abide”

Aufnahmen

DatumTitelEigenschaftenKünstlerLänge
recordings
Messiah: Appendix. Recitative: But who may abideDunedin Consort, John Butt0:27